Topiry 
DOOM: The Dark Ages Review: Slower, Heavier, Still Ferocious
After two games built almost entirely around momentum — dashing, double-jumping, and never letting your boots touch the ground for more than a second — DOOM: The Dark Ages does something genuinely bold. It slows down. Not in intensity, but in rhythm, trading the acrobatic ballet of 2020’s Eternal for something closer to a standing brawl, and against most expectations, it works.
Quick Verdict
A confident reinvention that swaps aerial combos for grounded, weighty brutality. The shield saw alone justifies the price of entry, and the medieval setting gives id Software’s art team its best canvas yet.
A Different Kind of Slayer
The Dark Ages is a prequel, and it uses that freedom to strip away the mobility toolkit players spent two games mastering. There’s no double jump, no dash-cancel combo chains, no air control tricks. Instead, the Slayer plants his feet and becomes an immovable object, tanking hits, parrying projectiles with the shield, and closing distance through sheer aggression rather than evasive footwork. It’s a genuine shift in identity, and the first few hours require unlearning muscle memory that Eternal spent years building.
Once it clicks, though, the new rhythm has its own addictive quality. Combat becomes a call-and-response of parry, counter, and execute rather than Eternal’s juggling act of resource management mid-air. Green projectiles beg to be shield-parried back at their source; melee-heavy demons demand you time a block and punish the opening. It’s more readable than Eternal’s chaos, which will be a relief for some players and a disappointment for those who loved the series’ peak-mobility high.
The Shield Saw and the New Arsenal
The star of the show is the shield saw, a combination melee weapon, ranged throwable, and traversal tool that can be flung to decapitate lesser demons or used to grind across gaps and zipline into melee range. It’s the best new toy id has added to the Slayer’s kit since the chainsaw became a resource-management staple, and the game builds entire encounter types specifically to show it off — corridors full of shield-saw switches, arenas designed around throw-and-recall loops.
The rest of the arsenal leans harder into physicality. Shotguns feel like they’re punching through armor plating rather than just dealing damage numbers, and a new flail weapon turns crowd-control into a genuinely satisfying spectacle of flying limbs. Weapon upgrade paths are simpler than Eternal’s sprawling mod trees, which some series veterans will miss, but the tradeoff is a combat kit that’s easier to parse mid-fight without pausing to check a loadout screen.
Mech Suits, Dragons, and Scale
Where The Dark Ages truly separates itself is in its set-piece variety. Giant mech-suit battles against Titan-scale demons play like a completely different game, all slow, weighty haymakers and building-leveling impact, and they’re spaced well enough that they never overstay their welcome. The dragon-riding sequences are more of a mixed bag — visually spectacular, with aerial dogfights over ruined cathedrals and lava fields, but mechanically simpler than the ground combat, functioning more as a palate-cleanser between the game’s meatier arena fights.
The medieval-demonic art direction is the best the series has ever looked. Gothic cathedrals fused with Hellish architecture, stained glass depicting the Slayer’s own mythologized legend, and lighting work that makes every arena feel like a painting you’re about to set on fire. This is a legitimate visual showcase, and on PC with ray-traced global illumination enabled, some vistas are genuinely jaw-dropping.
Performance on PC
id Tech continues to be one of the best-optimized engines in the industry, and The Dark Ages holds that tradition. The game hits high, stable frame rates even on modest hardware, with a generous settings menu that scales gracefully from integrated graphics up to 4K/144Hz on enthusiast rigs. Ray tracing options are additive rather than mandatory, and even with them maxed, performance overhead is reasonable compared to most current releases. Load times off an SSD are close to instantaneous, and we encountered no crashes across a full campaign playthrough.
Ultrawide and triple-monitor support are both properly implemented, field-of-view sliders go wide enough for competitive-shooter players used to maximum visibility, and the mouse feel is exactly what you’d hope from a studio that’s been refining this specific sensation for three console generations.
Level Design and Campaign Structure
Where Eternal built its campaign around tight, vertically stacked arenas that demanded constant aerial repositioning, The Dark Ages opts for broader, more horizontal spaces that give the Slayer room to charge, circle, and use the shield saw’s throw-and-recall loop without fighting the geometry. A handful of levels experiment with semi-open structure, letting you tackle optional side objectives — hidden armories, lore terminals detailing the Slayer’s mythologized history, secret Titan-scale encounters — in whatever order you like before committing to the main story path forward.
This isn’t an open-world game by any stretch, and it doesn’t want to be. The pacing remains tightly authored, with the campaign’s roughly 20-hour runtime built almost entirely around hand-placed encounters rather than procedural filler. Difficulty options are generous, ranging from a story-focused mode that lets newcomers enjoy the spectacle without punishing failure, up to a Nightmare-tier difficulty that will test even series veterans’ parry timing.
Sound Design and Mick Gordon’s Absence
The soundtrack, handled by a returning id Software audio team rather than the departed Mick Gordon, leans further into orchestral bombast alongside the series’ signature industrial metal, and the shift suits the medieval setting well. Choral elements underscore the game’s cathedral-heavy environments in a way that pure metal couldn’t have managed, though longtime fans of Gordon’s specific sound design on 2016 and Eternal may notice the difference in texture during the game’s most chaotic combat peaks. Sound design elsewhere is exceptional — the visceral crunch of the shield saw connecting with a demon’s skull is one of the most satisfying impact sounds in any shooter this year.
Who Should Play This
Fans of the series’ combat identity will find plenty to love here, though it’s worth going in with the right expectations: this is a heavier, more grounded game than Eternal, closer in spirit to a brawler than a movement shooter. Newcomers to the franchise will actually find this the most approachable entry to date, thanks to the more readable, parry-driven combat loop and a difficulty curve that ramps more gently than either of its predecessors.
Recommended PC Specs
True to id Tech’s reputation, hardware requirements here are refreshingly modest. A GTX 1660-class card will comfortably handle 1080p at high settings, while an RTX 4070 or equivalent pushes 4K at a locked 60fps with ray tracing enabled on most scenes. We tested across three different GPU tiers and saw consistent, predictable scaling with no unexpected bottlenecks at any tier — a rarity for a game this visually ambitious. 16GB of RAM is plenty, and an SSD is recommended primarily for load times rather than being a hard requirement for texture streaming, unlike some of its UE5-based contemporaries.
Multiplayer and Replay Value
Beyond the campaign, The Dark Ages includes a horde-style survival mode built around escalating waves of demons across remixed campaign arenas, giving the shield saw and mech-suit mechanics a dedicated space to be pushed to their absolute limit outside of scripted encounters. It’s a solid, if not groundbreaking, addition, and it extends the game’s replay value meaningfully for players chasing leaderboard times or simply looking for an excuse to keep parrying projectiles after the credits roll. Combined with three difficulty tiers and a New Game Plus mode that carries over unlocked weapon upgrades, there’s a healthy amount of reason to return once the story concludes.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Shield saw is a genuinely great new mechanic | Loses some of Eternal’s aerial mobility highs |
| Best art direction in series history | Dragon sections are visually strong but mechanically thin |
| Excellent, near-flawless PC optimization | Simplified weapon mod system may disappoint deep customizers |
| Mech and Titan battles are a genuine highlight | First few hours require relearning old habits |
Closing Thoughts
What impresses most about The Dark Ages, beyond any individual mechanic, is the confidence of the pivot itself. id Software could have easily shipped a safe, iterative sequel that simply added new guns and new demons to the Eternal formula, and it probably would have sold just as well. Instead, the studio bet that a fundamentally different combat rhythm, married to a genuinely stunning new aesthetic direction, was worth the risk of alienating players who’d spent years mastering the old system. That bet mostly pays off, and the handful of places where it doesn’t — the simplified weapon customization, the comparatively thin dragon sections — feel like reasonable tradeoffs rather than genuine missteps.
Final Verdict
DOOM: The Dark Ages is a rare prequel that justifies its own existence by being tonally and mechanically distinct rather than a victory lap. It won’t replace Eternal in the hearts of players who worship its ballistic mobility, but taken on its own terms, it’s a confident, gorgeous, and frequently exhilarating reinvention of what a Slayer power fantasy can look like.
Topiry Score: 8.8 / 10 — A bold structural pivot that mostly pays off, backed by the best presentation id Software has ever shipped.
About the Author
